◉ HEADLINES

No misconduct, judicial appointments constitutional: AGC amid calls of inquiry

AGC says appointments made with YDPA’s consent, based on the PM’s advice, and rejects comparisons to past cases of interference

12:30 PM MYT

 

KUALA LUMPUR – The Attorney-General’s Chambers (AGC) today clarified that judicial appointments, including top posts such as the chief justice and Court of Appeal president, follow processes outlined in the Federal Constitution and must be handled in an orderly and proper manner.

In a statement, the AGC said the process involves multiple considerations, including consultation requirements and the prime minister’s constitutional duty to advise the Yang di-Pertuan Agong, not merely act as a conduit for recommendations. 

The AGC also confirmed that the king had consented to the appointment of several judges last month, pending the completion of formalities. 

The statement came in response to Pandan MP Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli and several others who urged the establishment of a Commission of Inquiry and a Parliamentary Select Committee to scrutinise judicial appointments. The AGC stressed that while public confidence is important, the independence of the judiciary must be preserved. 

Citing Article 122B of the Federal Constitution, the AGC said judicial appointments are made by the King on the advice of the prime minister, after consulting the Conference of Rulers. While the Judicial Appointments Commission Act 2009 guides candidate selection, the constitutional authority to advise the King rests solely with the Prime Minister. 

Addressing concerns over a Judicial Appointments Commission (JAC) meeting allegedly convened without sufficient notice, the AGC said the JAC may regulate its own procedures. Urgent meetings on short notice are allowed if all members agree, and such procedural matters do not invalidate decisions unless there is clear evidence of bad faith or prejudice. 

The AGC also addressed serious allegations that a Federal Court judge influenced case outcomes or judge transfers, saying such claims are speculative at this point. JAC deliberations are confidential and protected by law, and these claims do not equate to proven misconduct. 

Comparisons to the 2007 VK Lingam case were dismissed as premature and unwarranted. That case involved concrete evidence of interference, unlike the current situation, which the AGC said involves only unproven allegations and procedural questions. 

While acknowledging Parliament’s power to investigate institutional governance, the AGC warned against politicising the constitutional roles of the king and prime minister. It stressed that any intervention must be guided by credible evidence and constitutional prudence. 

It urged all parties to refrain from speculation and public pressure campaigns, warning that timing discrepancies or procedural concerns do not constitute a constitutional crisis. – July 8, 2025

Topics

 

◉ Popular

No plans to scrap RON95 subsidies for T20 group for now : Loke

The government has no immediate plans to remove RON95 fuel subsidies for high-income earners, with Transport Minister Anthony Loke saying the Budi95 system will remain in place as Putrajaya prioritises a simpler and more efficient subsidy mechanism

PM Term Limit Bill falls two votes short in Dewan Rakyat, sparks disappointment among Madani MPs

The proposed constitutional amendment to cap the prime minister’s tenure at 10 years failed to secure a two-thirds majority in the Dewan Rakyat, drawing sharp reactions from leaders within the Madani coalition who described the outcome as a missed opportunity for institutional reform

Next FAM chief must ‘work 100 times harder’ to drive reforms: Hamidin

Incoming Football Association of Malaysia president must go beyond football knowledge and commit to governance and structural reforms

◉ Related